The Neat Company Forums

Welcome to The Neat Company Forums Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Buy or Not Buy....NeatReceipts??

Last post 09-29-2009, 12:44 AM by stairman. 5 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  08-10-2009, 11:29 AM 6722

    Buy or Not Buy....NeatReceipts??

    Wow, I have looked at the forum and by all indication this product seems to cause as many problems as the frustrations of a MANUAL system....I would like to see if I'm wasting my time in consdering buying this product.

    1) I have multiple companies that I gather receipts on...

    2) Most of my receipts are credit card transactions that I need to CATEGORIZE by Expense Category so my accountant can get it into QBooks as they pay the Credit Card Invoice for the month. 

         a) Is it possible to categorize all of the expenses on a purchase of a credit card receipt?  Everything I've read seems to indicate "NO"

         b) Are you able to Group by "Credit Card Account" so that I can give to my accountant?

                 Company #1:   Credit Card # xxxx-xx-1111       $99.00     Receipt Date:   7/31/2009     Vendor:  Home Depot

                                                                                                  $50.00  Equipment Repairs

                                                                                                  $49.00  Computer Supplies

     

                Company #2:   Credit Card #  xxxx-xx-9999      $25.00      Receipt Date:  7/31/2009        Vendor:  Office Depot

                                                                                                  $12.00   Office Supplies

                                                                                                  $13.00   Printing & Reproduction Expense

     

    Before I go out and invest time to buy and learn the system, I thought the EXPERTS in the forum may be able to shed light on these subjects.  I want to be able to give my accountant my CASH Expenditure Receipts report for the MONTH by COMPANY (I have multiple) and to have a document that shows how much I spent by Credit Card # and the categories of expenses associated that I can attach the document/report to the Credit Card Statement I receive from the Bank.

     

    Am I expecting TOO MUCH??

     

     

     

     

     

     

  •  08-13-2009, 1:51 AM 6727 in reply to 6722

    • jbenson2 is not online. Last active: 26 Aug 2009, 10:50 PM jbenson2
    • Top 75 Contributor
    • Joined on 12-21-2007
    • Minneapolis, MN
    • Contributor

    Re: Buy or Not Buy....NeatReceipts??

    I can't comment about your business questions, but I will say NeatWorks is a tedious program to install. And once you have scanned a couple hundred receipts, you will find the backup process is very lengthy. I am worried that the program lacks scalability. The solution NeatWorks suggests is to export your data to maintain a smaller file. That is possible, but it requires unzipped the archived file to import it back in for any sort of review.
  •  08-29-2009, 9:36 PM 6789 in reply to 6722

    Re: Buy or Not Buy....NeatReceipts??

    I process about 3 companies on one file and it works great.  I can certainly tell you that if you hate being unorganized and you hate clutter, then NeatReceipts is for you. Check out my easy short videos in youtube by following the link below:

     

    http://www.youtube.com/user/ar159101#play/uploads/11/1mbpbf9S1vg

  •  09-12-2009, 11:14 PM 6858 in reply to 6789

    Re: Buy or Not Buy....NeatReceipts??

    STOP DON'T BUY.

    The software is ok but the scanner is a joke. 

     

  •  09-16-2009, 2:42 PM 6874 in reply to 6858

    Re: Buy or Not Buy....NeatReceipts??

    My experiences have been mixed Caveat Emptor and all that...

    The instructions/help files are a joke. It tells you what any high level cretin can deduce, but there's NO help for details.

    Customizing is an absolute nightmare. They advertise that the information can be exported to Excel.

    BUT WAIT- THERE's MORE! NOT SO FAST, THERE, SPARKY!

    The program is trying to be everything for everyone - store receipts, documents, tax records, business cards, whatever, categorizing and storing the information, making out tax forms, and more.

    I've gone through Hell trying to just scan receipts, add data when the OCR can't make out information, and export to my company's Excel report.

    I've ended up with an ALMOST usable solution, which means remembering that this or that category is really something else, exporting to an Excel file page, then running a macro on the Excel file to format and place things where they are needed. I just need 6 columns for numeric expense types, a date column, and 4 columns of alpha information like vendor, remarks, location and one more. I now have to enter information in "dollar amount only" categories and reformat the info in the Excel macro. Clumsy at best.

    It is almost impossible to set the categories you NEED and delete or hide those you don't, which only serve to clutter up the process. 

    Thus far, trying to export the scanned receipts in picture form to the page in the Excel sheet has made it with mixed success. Small (like check stubs) receipts end up terribly distorted in the Excel page, but look great in the NEAT program. Whole page receipts (like hotel bills) end up tiny. If you do one receipt per page the file bloats beyond emailability. And the receipt images often end up split between two pages, unless you dork with the Excel page setup each time. now that's a needless chore.

    I've spent over 45 man hours trying to make this thing work. Took a while to figure out that when exporting to an Excel file, after you specify what columns and what row to start, the program INSERTS rows beginning at that line, so any references you have elsewhere in the form are screwed up, and your form grows in length by the number of receipts. Anything else I have used to export to Excel puts the data in the spaces provided and doesn't mess with your form. Boy, was that a bad assumption! So I end up exporting to a different page and then copying the data and formatting it with a macro. Kinda like making love wearing a flying suit, mittens and an oxygen mask. Very clumsy and not very satisfying.

    The scanner is pretty nifty and is handy to keep in the travel bag for just about any kind of scanning. Works quite well, in fact, in XP, and Vista (shudder). The scanner is worth $80 or so. The package isn't worth $400 IMHO.

    I'm dumping VISTA (another story) and loading XP on this machine soon. Alas, there seems to be no way to copy the settings I have made thus far, so it is back to square one, it appears.

    Surprisingly, the OCR on the scanned images works better than I have seen elsewhere.

    There seems to be no way to keep records in a central database and use the program on two machines - in other words, I have to use my laptop to do the reconciling and report generation, rather than being able to being the data to my desktop at home, with the big screen, printers, etc.

    Support? Hmmm... that's a toughie. From time to time NEAT folks will reply on the forum and they DO try to help. But there seems to be a mindset of "that's the way it is, and that's the way it will stay", or "Jeeze, I just don't know..."

    If you are cool with using their form and their template as is, and constantly wading through a lot of stuff you don't need and can't hide or delete, then go ahead and buy it. If not, you can find this little scanner elsewhere for a lot less than the package price.

    Want to have some fun? Stop by one of the NEAT airport kiosks. Start asking pointed questions on the subjects I have listed above. You see more blank stares and/or tapdancing than a Gregory Hynes revival. To quote the late Jackie Gleason, "ahhh, hummanah hummanah hummanah..." It's quite entertaining although hardly informative.

    I don't wish to offend anyone at NEAT, but I'm from farming stock, and if I see horsecrap, I call it horsecrap. You had the opportunity to make a really sterling product here, but dropped the ball as far as I can tell. If the product can do what I have mentioned, then TELL US HOW!!! If I am wrong about anything I have put forth, I WELCOME input from NEAT or anyone else if it helps me make this product work to what I believe are its advertised abilities.

    Yours for Better Television,

    -- Doc

    www.dumont.tv

     

     

     

  •  09-29-2009, 12:44 AM 6911 in reply to 6874

    Re: Buy or Not Buy....NeatReceipts??

    Wow, quite the review! But no response from Neat? InterestingIndifferent
View as RSS news feed in XML